3
Comment
Advocare7.4

Chances are you have heard of Advocare, one of the most well known companies in the multi-level marketing world.  Advocare offers both standard and vegan health shakes, though unfortunately, the vegan shakes contain both soy protein and fructose.  However, the standard shake comes in 4 different flavors,

Ingredients
7.1
Results
7
Safety
7
Value
8.3
7
Comment
Myoplex Lite7.3

There are a few positive aspects about this product – it contains 20 grams of protein, 1.5 grams of fat, 180 calories, and has a good nutritional value – but Myoplex seems to be a little old fashioned in the health and fitness world, as their formula consists of a plethora of chemicals and

Ingredients
6.5
Results
7.9
Safety
6.7
Value
8.2
4
Comment
Bill Phillips Right Light Shake7.2

The Bill Phillips Right Light Shakes are extremely popular in the world of meal replacement shakes, so we decided to give the ingredients a closer look.  This shake contains a whey and milk protein base, at 22 grams of protein per serving,  with over 50% of the recommended daily allowance of vitamins and

Ingredients
6.9
Results
7.6
Safety
7
Value
7.1
4
Comment
Idealshape

Idealshape ..we love the fact that this is a direct to consumer (non MLM) shake. This frequently equates to more expensive ingredients at a lower price point because they do not have to pay high fees to distributors and middlemen. However in this particular case, even though it has a great price point,

Ingredients
6.8
Results
7.6
Safety
7.1
Value
7.1
7
Comment
Slim-Fast7.1

Slim Fast is an extremely well-known health shake that has been seen on shelves of grocery stores for quite awhile now.  We decided to take a closer look into the French vanilla shake mix.  It is popular because of its good flavor and the fact that it contains a good amount of vitamins and minerals […]

Ingredients
6.5
Results
6.7
Safety
6.9
Value
8.3
3
Comment
Medifast Program7.1

Medifast has recently been fined $3.7 million for stating false weight loss claims, but while reviewing this shake, we tried not to let that hinder our opinion.  However, upon seeing the ingredients used, we were not impressed. Controversial Ingredients: This drink contains a soy protein isolate which by

Ingredients
6.6
Results
7
Safety
6.9
Value
7.9
2
Comment
USANA Nutrimeal7

Nutrimeal from USANA is a meal replacement shake with a soy protein base, which isn’t the best ingredient to use, as we prefer whey protein bases much more.  The next ingredient is fructose, which we ideally like to stay away from as well.  Dr. Mercoloa has reviewed numerous studies and research

Ingredients
6.9
Results
7.2
Safety
7
Value
7
2
Comment
HMR 5007

This meal replacement shake markets themselves as an aid to help those who are obese and they claim that it is medically supervised.  However, we have not been able to verify these claims.  Looking into their ingredients we have found that this shake is low in calories, but unfortunately, also low in

Ingredients
6.8
Results
7
Safety
6.9
Value
7.4
3
Comment
Metabolife Slender Satisfaction7

Metabolife Slender Satisfaction is a product that is targeted for women, utilizing a whey and soy blend.  We like the fact that it is a shake made for women, but we do not like that they use a soy protein at all. Metabolife has a large following behind its products, but with the presence of […]

Ingredients
6.4
Results
6.9
Safety
6.5
Value
8.2
2
Comment
Secure6.8

Where to start?  The Secure Complete Meal Replacement Shakes contain a good amount of nutrients, vitamins and minerals, but they also contain fillers and ingredients that we are not fans of. Controversial Ingredients: Secure Shakes have a soy protein isolate, which is not an ideal protein source to us.

Ingredients
6.5
Results
6.9
Safety
6.9
Value
7

Top 3 Diet Shakes

#1
310 Shake

#2
Wav Smart

#3
EVOLV

Highest Rated Brands